AI Video Editing Flows

Editing ad footage into creative variations

Workflows for cutting one master video into many ad variations by changing hooks, captions, calls to action and aspect ratios. This section works with real footage only.

The job and the deliverable

The job: take one finished ad and turn it into many versions by changing the hook, the call to action and the aspect ratio, so you can see which versions work. Think of it as a grid: hooks across, calls to action down, aspect ratios as a third layer.

The deliverable: a folder of finished files with a naming scheme that says which hook, call to action and ratio each one is, plus a one-page sheet listing them. For example, 3 hooks x 2 calls to action x 3 aspect ratios is 18 files.

This is our own guidance, now with one measured run. We built the grid below by script with FFmpeg only, on three source clips of an open film, and report it under What we ran ourselves. We have not tested any other tool for this job, and the research found almost no open tool that edits real footage into ad variations.

What you need

  • A master cut that is finished and approved, with a middle section you will not change.
  • The list of hooks (first seconds) and calls to action (last seconds), written as text.
  • The aspect ratios you need, with the safe zone for each platform.
  • A naming scheme, for example hookA_ctaX_9x16.mp4.
  • Rules from legal or the client about claims, so a new hook cannot add a claim nobody approved.
  • A way to check every output: file size, duration and a human look.

Recommended workflow

  1. Operator: lock the master. Decide what is allowed to vary (hook, call to action, captions, ratio) and what is not.
  2. Operator: record or cut the hook options and the call to action options as separate short clips that all share one frame rate, one size and one audio sample rate. The join step depends on that. See Join videos with FFmpeg without errors.
  3. Tool: assemble each version by script. If the parts match, the FFmpeg concat method joins them without re-encoding; if they do not match, normalize them first. A coding agent can write the script from your sheet, and you read it before it runs.
  4. Tool: make each aspect ratio as a real reframe, not a squeeze. Check that text and faces survive each crop and stay inside the safe zone. For the end card and counters, templates such as Logo sting and Count-up numbers can take the brand and numbers as settings.
  5. Tool: run a check script that prints duration, size and codec of every output with ffprobe, and flag any that differ from the master.
  6. Operator: watch the first and last 5 seconds of every file and one full run of each ratio. Approve the set.

What we ran ourselves

One master cut, three hook options, two end cards and three aspect ratios, built and joined by one FFmpeg script: 18 files per source clip, named hook<A-C>_cta<X-Y>_<ratio>.mp4. We ran it on three source clips of Tears of Steel, one cold run and three timed runs each. The script, the numbers and the frames are on our ad variations test; the join step is on Join videos with FFmpeg without errors.

  • The whole grid took a median of 95.2, 107.2 and 101.8 seconds per source clip, and all 18 names were present on every clip.
  • Our first version centred the text in the frame and 33 of 45 text lines sat inside the safe zone; at 9:16 four lines ran past the zone's wider right margin on each clip. Centring the text in the zone and shrinking long lines gave 45 of 45.
  • Joining parts by stream copy worked only because every part of a ratio had the same size, frame rate and audio settings. A hook at 30 fps and 44.1 kHz joined to the master produced FFmpeg warnings about non-monotonic timestamps, and in the joined file the picture and the sound ended at different times.
  • The audio track of each file ran 0.021 s longer than the picture.

Not run by us: Agentic Video Editor, remotion-ad-video-skill and any hosted ad tool. We did not test which version performs better.

Alternative route

The manual route: build a template project in your editing app, with the middle locked, and swap the hook and call to action clips by hand for each version. Export presets handle the ratios. This fits when you need only a handful of versions.

The code route in our workflow fits when the grid is large or repeats every week. We found one open tool aimed at this job, Agentic Video Editor, which turns raw footage and a brief into a short ad using Gemini agents for decisions and FFmpeg for rendering. The library flags it as stale: only 6 commits, a pre-alpha web UI, a Google AI key required, and no commits since April. We have not tested it.

A second open item, remotion-ad-video-skill, makes an agent write an ad brief file before it renders. It shows no real-footage output, and Remotion's company licence applies to production use.

Quality checklist

  • File names match the sheet, and no version is missing or duplicated.
  • Every version has the length you planned and the same audio level as the master.
  • Hooks and calls to action change only what you intended; no claim was added or dropped.
  • Captions match the new hook, not the master's old first line.
  • Text, faces and logos sit inside the safe zone of every ratio.
  • Frame rate, size and codec are the same across versions of one ratio.
  • A human watched at least the start, the join points and the end of each file.

Known problems

Joining parts that differ in size, frame rate or audio sample rate causes errors or timing problems. We measured this with FFmpeg on test files; the results are on Join videos with FFmpeg without errors.

Swapping a hook changes loudness and pace at the join. Listen at every join.

Captions are the easiest thing to forget. A new hook needs new captions.

Version sprawl: more files than a person can review. Decide how many you can actually check before you generate them.

Generated variations can drift from what was approved. Keep the approved master and the sheet as the source of truth.

Tools for this job are rare and young. We have one tested pipeline, our own FFmpeg script, and no benchmark of other tools.

Tools and effects for this job

Logo sting

A short logo hit for intros, outros and ad end cards, reusable for any mark.

FFmpeg command builder

Build an FFmpeg command for common edits such as trim, join, convert and compress an MP4 file. Choose the job, set the options, copy the command.

We built 18 versions of one ad with FFmpeg: 3 hooks, 2 calls to action, 3 ratios

We built 18 ad versions from one master with FFmpeg: 3 hooks, 2 calls to action, 3 aspect ratios. Timings, file sizes, safe-zone and loudness checks.

Pages on this site that help with ad variations: effects you can restyle quickly and a command builder.

Reviewed picks from other creators

The few tools and skills we found for ad variations. Every card is a draft until the owner reviews it.

Source page screenshot, captured 2026-11-07

remotion-ad-video-skill (ad-brief.json contract)

By leosssvip-dot on GitHub

MIT skill that builds ad videos from a brief file. The catch is that Remotion's company licence may apply and no real footage output is shown.

Use it for: Generates ad video variations from a structured brief.

Licence, price and checks
  • Licence MIT
  • Reuse Remotion licence (free up to 3 employees)
  • Price Free
  • Library check likely works, Oct 17, 2026

Source reviewed on Oct 17, 2026. Not tested by us.

For teams that make this every week

If your team makes ad variations every week, tell us about your grid, your stack and where the time goes. This is the job where we have the least outside evidence.

If your team makes this kind of video every week, tell us the job, the tools you use, how many you make a week and where it gets stuck: contact us. We read every message; there is no form to fill in and no account.

Page checked on Nov 4, 2026.