Stick-figure comedy and explainer reels: measured cuts, length and loudness
Stickman / simple 2D comedy and explainers: 5 pages and 50 reels measured, 8 reels torn down, 2 of them with a full teardown page. All figures were measured on 5 Nov 2026.
The format in numbers
The first group of rows comes from the Format scoreboard in our theme-pages workbook, which we recomputed from the raw files. The second group is measured on the torn-down reels of this format.
| Measure | Value | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Pages measured | 5 | Scoreboard |
| Reels measured | 50 | Scoreboard, all reels of these pages we collected |
| Median plays per reel | 20,537 | Scoreboard, median of the pages' median plays |
| Plays per follower, median across pages | 2.94 | Scoreboard |
| Reels at 3x or more of their own page median | 19 of 50 | Scoreboard |
| Posts per week, median across pages | 7 | Scoreboard |
| Confidence | Higher | Scoreboard: set by the number of pages measured |
| Reels torn down | 8 | Our measurement of the files |
| Median length of torn-down reels | 23.2 s | Our measurement of the files |
| Median hard cuts per minute | 14.4 | Our measurement of the files |
| Median big visual changes per minute | 10.2 | Our measurement of the files |
| Median integrated loudness | -14.1 LUFS | Over the 8 torn-down reels with an audio track |
| Median speech pace | 3.33 words per second | Over the 6 torn-down reels with speech |
What we saw frame by frame
These counts come from the frame-by-frame notes of 5 reels of this format. A model read the contact sheets, and we counted keywords in its notes, so read the counts as approximate.
- 1 of 5 reels: no speech.
- 2 of 5 reels: captions that follow the speech word by word or phrase by phrase.
- 1 of 5 reels: text that stays still for the whole reel or most of it.
- 2 of 5 reels: an emphasis colour on a key word.
- 1 of 5 reels: a viewer question or prompt in the post caption.
- 2 of 5 reels: no end card.
- 1 of 5 reels: one new picture or composition per spoken phrase, sentence or beat.
- 3 of 5 reels: sound effects or ASMR-style sound described.
Teardowns of this format
- Teardown #06: a short stick-figure comedy reel that ends on a hard cut to a real reaction clip
- Teardown #07: a long doodle explainer where every voice-over sentence gets a new illustration or chart
Effects we have for this
Each row is a match to something the notes say a reel of this format shows. It is our closest effect, not a claim about what the creator used.
| What the reel does | Our closest effect | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Two-line comic-style caption at the top of the frame, static through the cartoon part. | Shorts, Reels and TikTok safe zone overlay | Seen in teardown #06. Check that a fixed caption sits clear of the app's buttons. |
| A 'LOW ENERGY USE' gauge in the doodle art. | Usage arc meter | Seen in teardown #07. Our closest effect for a gauge. |
| A 'Respiration' chart and a bar chart ('Males / Females'). | Animated data chart | Seen in teardown #07. Our closest effect for simple charts. |
What we would test before copying it
- Whether the reach holds on a page that is not already a hit. We found these pages through hashtags, which favour pages that already had one, and only 5 pages are measured.
- Whether the editing pattern or the premise drives the plays. The data cannot separate the two.
- Retention, shares and follows. These cannot be seen from outside Instagram.
- Whether a page that posts at the median of 7 posts a week keeps its numbers over a longer run. We measured each page on its last ~10 reels only.
Method and limits
- Plays, likes, comments, followers and posting dates were collected from Instagram by Apify on 5 Nov 2026.
- For each of 69 pages we took the best reel and a typical reel of its last ten, 138 reels in all, and measured the files by script.
- Ratio to the page median is plays divided by the median plays of the page's last ten reels, as measured on 5 Nov 2026.
- Format statistics are recomputed here from the raw files and compared with the workbook's Format scoreboard; any difference is recorded under recheck.
- Pattern counts per format are keyword searches over the frame-by-frame notes of that format, so read them as approximate.
- Hard-cut counts miss dissolves, so a reel built on dissolves can show close to zero hard cuts.
- The big visual change count also counts camera travel and scene changes, so it is not the same as the cut count. We show both.
- Some full-HD files had no audio track, so loudness and speech are blank for those reels.
- Plays include replays. Shares and follower conversion cannot be seen from outside.
- Ten reels from one page are not ten independent tests.
- Hashtag discovery favours pages that already had a hit, so breakout pages are over-represented.
- Plays per follower favours small, newer pages; it measures reach health, not size.
- Formats measured on only one to three pages are hypotheses.
- No number here is a promise about what a new reel will do.
Plays and followers as shown on Instagram on 5 Nov 2026. The scoreboard rows matched our recomputation from the raw files on every field; the check re-runs the same arithmetic on the same files, so it does not test the method.
Page checked on Nov 4, 2026.