AI Video Editing Flows

Stick-figure comedy and explainer reels: measured cuts, length and loudness

Stickman / simple 2D comedy and explainers: 5 pages and 50 reels measured, 8 reels torn down, 2 of them with a full teardown page. All figures were measured on 5 Nov 2026.

The format in numbers

The first group of rows comes from the Format scoreboard in our theme-pages workbook, which we recomputed from the raw files. The second group is measured on the torn-down reels of this format.

MeasureValueSource
Pages measured5Scoreboard
Reels measured50Scoreboard, all reels of these pages we collected
Median plays per reel20,537Scoreboard, median of the pages' median plays
Plays per follower, median across pages2.94Scoreboard
Reels at 3x or more of their own page median19 of 50Scoreboard
Posts per week, median across pages7Scoreboard
ConfidenceHigherScoreboard: set by the number of pages measured
Reels torn down8Our measurement of the files
Median length of torn-down reels23.2 sOur measurement of the files
Median hard cuts per minute14.4Our measurement of the files
Median big visual changes per minute10.2Our measurement of the files
Median integrated loudness-14.1 LUFSOver the 8 torn-down reels with an audio track
Median speech pace3.33 words per secondOver the 6 torn-down reels with speech

What we saw frame by frame

These counts come from the frame-by-frame notes of 5 reels of this format. A model read the contact sheets, and we counted keywords in its notes, so read the counts as approximate.

  • 1 of 5 reels: no speech.
  • 2 of 5 reels: captions that follow the speech word by word or phrase by phrase.
  • 1 of 5 reels: text that stays still for the whole reel or most of it.
  • 2 of 5 reels: an emphasis colour on a key word.
  • 1 of 5 reels: a viewer question or prompt in the post caption.
  • 2 of 5 reels: no end card.
  • 1 of 5 reels: one new picture or composition per spoken phrase, sentence or beat.
  • 3 of 5 reels: sound effects or ASMR-style sound described.

Teardowns of this format

  • Teardown #06: a short stick-figure comedy reel that ends on a hard cut to a real reaction clip
  • Teardown #07: a long doodle explainer where every voice-over sentence gets a new illustration or chart

Effects we have for this

Each row is a match to something the notes say a reel of this format shows. It is our closest effect, not a claim about what the creator used.

What the reel doesOur closest effectNote
Two-line comic-style caption at the top of the frame, static through the cartoon part.Shorts, Reels and TikTok safe zone overlaySeen in teardown #06. Check that a fixed caption sits clear of the app's buttons.
A 'LOW ENERGY USE' gauge in the doodle art.Usage arc meterSeen in teardown #07. Our closest effect for a gauge.
A 'Respiration' chart and a bar chart ('Males / Females').Animated data chartSeen in teardown #07. Our closest effect for simple charts.

What we would test before copying it

  • Whether the reach holds on a page that is not already a hit. We found these pages through hashtags, which favour pages that already had one, and only 5 pages are measured.
  • Whether the editing pattern or the premise drives the plays. The data cannot separate the two.
  • Retention, shares and follows. These cannot be seen from outside Instagram.
  • Whether a page that posts at the median of 7 posts a week keeps its numbers over a longer run. We measured each page on its last ~10 reels only.

Method and limits

  • Plays, likes, comments, followers and posting dates were collected from Instagram by Apify on 5 Nov 2026.
  • For each of 69 pages we took the best reel and a typical reel of its last ten, 138 reels in all, and measured the files by script.
  • Ratio to the page median is plays divided by the median plays of the page's last ten reels, as measured on 5 Nov 2026.
  • Format statistics are recomputed here from the raw files and compared with the workbook's Format scoreboard; any difference is recorded under recheck.
  • Pattern counts per format are keyword searches over the frame-by-frame notes of that format, so read them as approximate.
  • Hard-cut counts miss dissolves, so a reel built on dissolves can show close to zero hard cuts.
  • The big visual change count also counts camera travel and scene changes, so it is not the same as the cut count. We show both.
  • Some full-HD files had no audio track, so loudness and speech are blank for those reels.
  • Plays include replays. Shares and follower conversion cannot be seen from outside.
  • Ten reels from one page are not ten independent tests.
  • Hashtag discovery favours pages that already had a hit, so breakout pages are over-represented.
  • Plays per follower favours small, newer pages; it measures reach health, not size.
  • Formats measured on only one to three pages are hypotheses.
  • No number here is a promise about what a new reel will do.

Plays and followers as shown on Instagram on 5 Nov 2026. The scoreboard rows matched our recomputation from the raw files on every field; the check re-runs the same arithmetic on the same files, so it does not test the method.

Page checked on Nov 4, 2026.